Contrasting the dynamics of English  and Finnish education policy­making

Podcast Description

The presentation aims to understand and contrast the dynamics in English and Finnish education policy­making. Dynamics are understood as patterns of interaction between the main policy actors embedded in the socio­historical contexts in the two countries. Data is drawn from 16 theme interviews with key policymakers in England complemented with a body of official 
documents. The Finnish data is based on earlier research projects, their results and policymaker theme interview data used in them.
The English education policy­making on the surface level reflects a rather reactionary dynamics, following earlier theories of policy entrepreneurs seizing opportunities. On a deeper level, policymaking is guided by an institutional structure created over the course of history: centralisation of power to the Department for Education and a shift of balance in consulting from formal or professional organisations to think tanks and political advisors, and the ascendancy of Ofsted as a political actor in education policy. Finnish education policy­making dynamics is restricted by radical municipal autonomy, consensus supporting decision making system, and a bureaucratic tradition all which buffer against rapid changes and result in a continuity of the comprehensive school.
In policy-making, the relations of the English actors are conflictual whereas in Finland they are consensual. In both context there seemed to be a governance gap between the central and local administration. The difference in the processes of centralisation seemed to explain change potential. The main difference in dynamics is the fluidity of the education institutions, particularly school types. In England, the changing political emphasis has changed thebasic organisation of schooling, while in Finland changes took place inside the comprehensive school institution.

More from this series

    Podcast
    Government statistics indicate that children and young people with special educational needs are five times more likely to be excluded from secondary schools, and account for just under half of excluded pupils.
    25 February 2020
    Discover More
    Podcast
    The House of Commons’ Education Committee (2019) criticised the education system’s treatment of children with disabilities on the following terms: “[C]hildren and parents are not ‘in the know’ and for some the law may not even appear to exist.
    13 February 2020
    Discover More
    Podcast
    This talk will discuss the latest understanding of mental health needs in adolescent populations in the UK and the potential role that mental health services in schools can play.
    13 February 2020
    Discover More
    Podcast
    This seminar is part of our public seminar series on ‘Exclusion from School and its Consequences’, led by the Department of Education and convened by Harry Daniels (Professor of Education) and Ian Thompson (Associate Professor of English Education & Director of PGCE).
    4 February 2020
    Discover More
    Podcast
    There are great differences in the rates of permanent school exclusion in different parts of the UK with numbers rising rapidly in England but remaining relatively low or falling in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales.
    20 January 2020
    Discover More
    Podcast
    The use of expert panels to advise governments is a favoured form of policy inquiry process.
    19 November 2019
    Discover More