Reflections on global universities: spaces for South-South engagements
At the overseas universities, the legal requirements of fee cap and other provisions do not extend to international students. Further, their knowledges and lived experiences are often perceived as less valuable leading to a neglect of their views.
As a result, the issues pertaining to international students remain largely invisible. In some ways the national scales of policy discourse bar voices of international students. The need for greater recognition of international student voices is also minimised by their conventional portraits as individuals with considerable socio-economic privilege. It is important to acknowledge that international students are not just from socio-economically well-off communities, they also emerge from margins of Southern communities, pledging families’ earnings for access to education opportunities or promise of making a living. I
n search for new opportunities, students in developed and developing countries alike, opt for overseas education. And yet the challenges begin from the time of visa application, funding, all the way to classrooms and assessments where students are expected to attune to all new mechanisms, expectations and norms.
As the global crises expose the crevices of education systems, it also calls for rethinking international mobility and knowledge production. South-North engagements in student mobilities, research collaborations or knowledge production has been the norm owing to global systems that accorded them greater prestige. And yet, I wonder if this process has potential to pave way for South-South engagements that could help create meaningful dialogue and put forth reforms for a new era of student mobilities.
Drawing on my own international student experiences in Singapore, France, China and UK, I believe that the merits of South-South engagements cannot be overstated. During my recent fieldwork in India, I found that scholars resonated with the idea that greater academic interactions, collaborations and comparative studies with scholars from Brazil, South Africa or China can help build a new conceptual language in social science research. In my own research, analysing social science research in China provided valuable insights for the Indian case. Given the similarities in socio-economic and political issues that Southern nations experience, exchanges can offer prospects for innovative research.
As hubs for international students, universities offer forums for meaningful dialogue. In discussions with other South Asian colleagues, we would often reflect that university spaces like Oxford in some ways facilitate these discussions which cannot take place in the region due to political tensions. My own research on social science research in India and China had greater potential to be pursued in Oxford, enriched by experts on both the regions based in university which may not be possible otherwise.
Elsewhere, there have been promising initiatives made in this regard. The South Asian University (SAU) was formed by South Asian Association for Regional Co-operation to foster interactions amongst youth and build regional cohesion. Nalanda University is another project to create knowledge exchange across Southeast, South and East Asia. China has emerged as a salient hub for Southern students. Its plan for China-Africa Cooperation on talent development attempts to deepen interaction amongst students in the two regions.
Nonetheless, the realm of South-South academic engagements is strife with its own challenges. In a Centre for Global Higher Education (CGHE) research project on African students’ experiences in China, findings indicate that Northern orientation is prevalent in South-South interactions. Therefore, even when actors change the underlying dynamics of working remain the same. Political tensions amongst nations also deter the development of the above initiatives as in the case of SAU. However, given that these initiatives are recently formulated, we hope that they would be able to serve their potential in upcoming years. Thereby, research innovation across diverse spaces of South-South engagements can perhaps assist in overcoming challenges, offer new avenues for international students and recalibrate international higher education.
Written by Vedika Kedia